He asked: Will Warren be invited to the solemn ceremony of inauguration without being asked to repudiate what he has directly said to deny salvation to Jews? Will he be giving a national invocation without disowning what his ment…
The case -- Altria Group, Inc. v. Good -- was just announced. It's 5-4, with the majority opinion written by Justice Stevens and the dissenting opinion written by Justice Thomas. There's no need to spell out the rest of …
Chief Justice Roberts writes for the majority in Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council . He begins with a quote from George Washington: "To be prepared for war is one of the most effectual means of preserving peace.&q…
SCOTUSblog previews tomorrow's oral argument in Pleasant Grove City, et al., v. Summum . Will the Justices’ vision be fogged by a cloud of potential horribles? The Solicitor General’s brief well illustrates this argument: “U…
Lyle Denniston reports on the oral argument in Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts : [Justice Kennedy] foresaw ”a very substantial burden” on the prosecution and on the courts, and told counsel advocating for confrontation that he wa…
The Supreme Court declines to hear 2 cases about "victim impact" evidence in death sentencing, and 3 Justices protest: In the cases denied review on Monday, the evidence was composed of a 20-minute videotape in one cas…
23/6 has a few excerpts from the oral argument in FCC v. Fox Television Stations : Justice Scalia : The issue at hand is not whether stations can broadcast words like "freak" or "stuff," but whether children …
Asked Dan Drezner , quoted by Language Log's Geoff Nunberg in his post about the oral argument in the Supreme Court case about "fleeting expletives" in the broadcast media. (Kevin Martin is the FCC chairman who favo…
Justice Stevens asked yesterday in the argument about whether the FCC could fine a broadcaster for allowing a "fleeting expletive" to go out over the airwaves. Here 's the NYT account of the argument, with the usual…
He's rejecting the efficiency of the system of shared law clerks in which clerk writes a memo relied on by Justices using the pool to decide whether to grant the petition to the Supreme Court to hear a case. A petition accep…
I thought it was quite good. Though the story was mainly told from the Gore side, the Bush point of view was represented fairly, and there was a good overall balance to it. Complicated legal issues were explained surprising well …
Asks Linda Greenhouse , in a survey of the Roberts years on the Supreme Court that notes the decline of 5-4 decisions. There's only been 1 this year (and it was a "low-profile" statutory case where Justice Kennedy, …
So wrote Justice White in Coker v. Georgia , and this week, the Supreme Court takes up the question whether the death penalty could nevertheless be constitutional when the victim is a child. Those facts alone are a powerful argu…
SCOTUSblog reports: The newly granted case on monuments on public property — Pleasant Grove City v. Summum (06-665) — will return the Court to the thorny issue of government control of expressive displays in city parks and other …
This is the subject of Medellin v. Texas , argued — with great vigor — in the Supreme Court yesterday. SCOTUSblog summarizes: With cross-currents of constitutional and international law flowing freely, what appeared to be a majo…
1. It started — like my Fedcourts class — at 4, and I set the old Explorer 8000 to save it for me. So, let's go. Chris Matthews is asking the questions. The subject is the economy (so let's see who tries to leaven the dis…
The NYT would like to say that Clarence Thomas's anger disqualifies from hearing some cases. Isn't it insanely obvious that if a liberal black judge harbored anger for the way he was treated over the years, the NYT wou…
There's one more thing I've got to say about the Clarence Thomas memoir, "My Grandfather's Son." It's about Al Gore. Al Gore was ... candid when a friend of mine approached him [before the Supreme Court …
That's the question D.C. Circuit Judge Larry Silberman told Clarence Thomas he should ask himself in every case he had to decide. Thomas considered this to be "the best piece of advice I received, one that became central…